Western Refining: financial analysis
Ratios worked out from 8 fiscal years of Western Refining's statements, compared with 311 companies in Energy.
The newest statement on file is for fiscal 2016. The figures below describe that year, not Western Refining today.
Western Refining scorecard#
Passes 6 of the 16 checks that could be worked out: strongest in financial health (3 of 5), weakest in shareholder returns (1 of 5). Fiscal year 2016.
Valuationnot known
- –P/E below its peers' medianNo market cap.
- –Price to book below its peers' medianNo market cap.
- –Price to sales below its peers' medianNo market cap.
- –Free cash flow yield above 5%No market cap.
- –Earnings yield above the 10-year Treasury yieldNo market cap.
- –The price assumes slower growth than the last three years'No market cap.
Growth0 of 2
- –Revenue grew in the newest yearRevenue of the year before is not on file.
- –Revenue up more than 5% a year over three yearsRevenue of three years earlier is not on file.
- –Faster growth over three years than its peers' medianRevenue of three years earlier is not on file.
- ✗Earnings per share grew in the newest year1.24 vs 4.28Diluted EPS 1.24 in fiscal 2016 against 4.28 the year before (report's currency).
- ✗Net income higher than five years earlier$125 M$125 M in fiscal 2016 against $133 M in 2011.
- –Revenue rose in at least four of the last five yearsFive years of revenue changes are not on file.
Profitability2 of 4
- ✓Profitable in the newest year$125 MNet income $125 M in fiscal 2016.
- ✓Profitable in each of the last five years5 of 5Profitable in 5 of the five years to fiscal 2016.
- –Operating margin above its peers' medianNo operating margin on file.
- ✗Return on equity above 15%8.3%8.3% in fiscal 2016.
- ✗Return on invested capital above 10%9.7%9.7% in fiscal 2016.
- –Operating margin wider than three years earlierOperating margins of three years earlier are not on file.
Financial health3 of 5
- ✓Short-term assets cover short-term liabilities1.7×Current ratio 1.70 at the end of fiscal 2016.
- ✗Debt below equity1.1×Debt to equity 1.10 at the end of fiscal 2016.
- ✓Net debt below three years of EBITDA2.9×Net debt 2.9 times EBITDA in fiscal 2016.
- ✗Operating income covers interest five times2.8×Operating income 2.8 times interest in fiscal 2016.
- ✓Cash from operations positive in each of the last three years3 of 3Positive in 3 of the three years to fiscal 2016.
- –Altman Z-score outside the distress zoneThe Z-score's figures are not all on file.
Shareholder returns1 of 5
- ✓Pays a dividendYesPaid dividends in fiscal 2016.
- ✗Dividend per share raised five years in a row2 of 5Dividend per share raised in 2 of the five years to fiscal 2016.
- ✗Dividends under 75% of net income123.0%Dividends were 123.0% of net income in fiscal 2016.
- ✗Share count up no more than 2% in a year6.2%Diluted shares up 6.2% in fiscal 2016.
- –Dividends and buybacks above 3% of the market valueNo market cap.
- ✗Free cash flow covers dividends and buybacks$83 MFree cash flow $83 M against $229 M paid out in fiscal 2016.
Worked out from the statements as filed (sec), the medians of Energy, the 10-year Treasury yield of Nov 13, 2026 and the market cap (too old for the valuation checks, which need one at most 60 days old). A check that cannot be worked out counts neither way. A reading aid, not advice. How the checks work
What the 2016 statements show#
Each line is an observation with its numbers, not a judgement of the company.
Strengths
- Free cash flow has been positive 8 years in a row.
Worth a look
- The share count rose 6.2% in the year.
Piotroski F-score
Nine yes/no tests of whether the company's finances improved in the year. One point each.
- Made a profityes
- Operations brought in cashyes
- Return on assets roseno
- Cash from operations exceeds profityes
- Long-term debt fell against assetsno
- Current ratio roseno
- No new shares issuedno
- Gross margin rosenot on file
- Asset turnover rosenot on file
Profitability#
| Fiscal year | Trend | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | Median of peers | Ahead of |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Return on equity | 8.3% | 33.6% | 55.6% | 30.6% | 46.1% | 6.0% | 58% | |
| Return on assets | 2.2% | 7.1% | 10.1% | 6.9% | 15.8% | 2.6% | 47% | |
| Return on invested capital | 9.7% | 31.5% | 41.3% | 29.6% | 38.3% | 9.5% | 52% |
Growth#
| Fiscal year | Trend | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | Median of peers | Ahead of |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net income growth | -69.3% | -27.4% | 102.9% | -30.8% | 200.7% | -1.5% | 8% | |
| Earnings per share growth | -71.0% | -23.7% | 101.1% | -24.8% | 176.9% | -2.2% | 8% |
Financial strength#
| Fiscal year | Trend | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | Median of peers | Ahead of |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Debt to equity | 1.10× | 1.27× | 1.32× | 1.31× | 0.55× | 0.49× | 22% | |
| Net debt | $1.6 B | $872 M | $1.0 B | $705 M | $46 M | $877 M | 39% | |
| Net debt to EBITDA | 2.86× | 0.77× | 0.81× | 1.02× | 0.06× | 1.51× | 37% | |
| Interest cover | 2.79× | 8.81× | 11.30× | 7.67× | 8.75× | 1.66× | 63% | |
| Current ratio | 1.70× | 2.38× | 1.85× | 1.32× | 1.76× | 1.25× | 64% | |
| Equity share of assets | 30.5% | 22.3% | 19.9% | 16.3% | 36.7% | 47.0% | 26% |
Cash#
| Fiscal year | Trend | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | Median of peers | Ahead of |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free cash flow | $83 M | $552 M | $514 M | $235 M | $714 M | $56 M | 55% | |
| Cash conversion | 307.2% | 207.3% | 131.7% | 159.8% | 229.7% | 218.7% | 70% |
How each figure is worked out#
- Return on equity
- Net income as a share of shareholders' equity (the average of the start and the end of the year). Not given when equity is negative.
- Return on assets
- Net income as a share of total assets (average of the year).
- Return on invested capital
- Operating income after tax, as a share of debt plus equity less cash (average of the year). The tax rate is the year's own: income tax over pre-tax income.
- Net income growth
- Net income against the year before. Only when both years were profitable.
- Earnings per share growth
- Diluted earnings per share against the year before. Only when both were positive.
- Debt to equity
- Total debt divided by shareholders' equity. Not given when equity is negative.
- Net debt
- Total debt less cash. Negative means more cash than debt.
- Net debt to EBITDA
- Debt less cash, divided by operating income plus depreciation and amortization: roughly the years of operating earnings needed to repay it.
- Interest cover
- Operating income divided by the interest paid on debt.
- Current ratio
- Assets due within a year divided by liabilities due within a year.
- Equity share of assets
- Shareholders' equity as a share of total assets.
- Free cash flow
- Cash from operations less capital spending.
- Cash conversion
- Cash from operations as a share of net income. Only when the year was profitable.
- Dividend payout
- Dividends paid as a share of net income. Only when the year was profitable.
- Change in share count
- Diluted shares against the year before. Negative: fewer shares.
Source: Western Refining's statements: annual reports filed with the SEC. Arithmetic on reported figures, in US dollars; nothing is estimated. A figure is blank when a line it needs is not in the statements on file, and left out when the result cannot be right (a margin from next to no revenue). "Ahead of" is the share of the 311 companies in Energy that Western Refining is better than on that figure, using each company's newest fiscal year; yields use today's market value. Medians for every industry · Back to Western Refining