Five Below, Inc. vs Murphy USA Inc.
Market value, revenue, profit, valuation and financial strength side by side, each from the company's own filings or market data, with its date.
In short
- Five Below, Inc. is the larger company by market value: $12.3 B against $9.8 B for Murphy USA Inc., 1.3 times as much (market caps of Oct 16, 2026 for Five Below, Inc. and Oct 30, 2026 for Murphy USA Inc.).
- Murphy USA Inc. had more revenue: $19.4 B in the year to December 2025 against $4.8 B for Five Below, Inc. in the year to January 2026.
- Murphy USA Inc. earned more: net income of $471 M against $359 M for Five Below, Inc.
- Five Below, Inc. keeps more of each dollar of sales: a net margin of 7.5% against 2.4% for Murphy USA Inc.
- Five Below, Inc. employs more people: 21,900 against 16,900 at Murphy USA Inc. Each employee brings in about $217,541 of revenue at Five Below, Inc. and $1,146,982 at Murphy USA Inc.
- On price to earnings, Five Below, Inc. trades at 19.9× and Murphy USA Inc. at 14.7×: investors pay more for each dollar of Five Below, Inc.'s profit.
- Five Below, Inc.'s revenue grew faster in its latest fiscal year: +22.9% against -4.2% for Murphy USA Inc.
- Both are in the safe zone of the Altman Z-score.
Market value, the same start = 100
From Jan 2020: how each one's value moved, whatever its size.
Revenue by fiscal year
US$ billions, as reported in each year's annual results.
Side by side
| Measure | Five Below, Inc. FIVE · #1,869 in the world | Murphy USA Inc. MUSA · #2,221 in the world |
|---|---|---|
| Profile | ||
| Country | 🇺🇸 USA | 🇺🇸 USA |
| Sector | Consumer Cyclical | Consumer Cyclical |
| Industry | Retail - Speciality | Retail - Speciality |
| Founded | 2002 | 1996 |
| Size | ||
| Market cap | $12.3 B | $9.8 B |
| Revenue | $4.8 B | $19.4 B |
| Net income | $359 M | $471 M▲ best |
| Employees | 21,900 | 16,900 |
| Valuation | ||
| P/E ratio | 19.9× | 14.7× |
| Price to sales | 2.3× | 0.4× |
| Price to book | 5.6× | 15.7× |
| Free cash flow yield | 3.4% | 3.8%▲ best |
| Profitability | ||
| Gross margin | 36.0% | — |
| Operating margin | 9.6%▲ best | 3.7% |
| Net margin | 7.5%▲ best | 2.4% |
| Return on equity | 17.9% | 64.3%▲ best |
| Growth | ||
| Revenue growth | 22.9%▲ best | -4.3% |
| Revenue growth, 3 years a year | 15.7%▲ best | -6.1% |
| Earnings per share growth | 40.6%▲ best | -0.0% |
| Cash | ||
| Free cash flow margin | 8.6%▲ best | 1.9% |
| Shareholder returns | ||
| Dividend yield | — | 0.4% |
| Shareholder yield | 0.0% | 7.1%▲ best |
| Altman Z-score zone | safe | safe |
| Data as of | Market cap Oct 2026; ratios FY2025 | Market cap Oct 2026; ratios FY2025 |
▲ marks the better of the two where higher or lower is better; size and valuation multiples are marked for neither
Questions and answers#
Which is bigger, Five Below, Inc. or Murphy USA Inc.?
Five Below, Inc. is the larger company by market value: $12.3 B against $9.8 B for Murphy USA Inc., 1.3 times as much (market caps of Oct 16, 2026 for Five Below, Inc. and Oct 30, 2026 for Murphy USA Inc.).
Which makes more money, Five Below, Inc. or Murphy USA Inc.?
Murphy USA Inc. had more revenue: $19.4 B in the year to December 2025 against $4.8 B for Five Below, Inc. in the year to January 2026. Murphy USA Inc. earned more: net income of $471 M against $359 M for Five Below, Inc.
Which is more profitable, Five Below, Inc. or Murphy USA Inc.?
Five Below, Inc. keeps more of each dollar of sales: a net margin of 7.5% against 2.4% for Murphy USA Inc.
Which has more employees, Five Below, Inc. or Murphy USA Inc.?
Five Below, Inc. employs more people: 21,900 against 16,900 at Murphy USA Inc. Each employee brings in about $217,541 of revenue at Five Below, Inc. and $1,146,982 at Murphy USA Inc.
Is Five Below, Inc. cheaper than Murphy USA Inc.?
On price to earnings, Five Below, Inc. trades at 19.9× and Murphy USA Inc. at 14.7×: investors pay more for each dollar of Five Below, Inc.'s profit. A lower multiple is not by itself a better buy: it also reflects expected growth, risk and accounting.
Which is growing faster, Five Below, Inc. or Murphy USA Inc.?
Five Below, Inc.'s revenue grew faster in its latest fiscal year: +22.9% against -4.2% for Murphy USA Inc.
Which is financially stronger, Five Below, Inc. or Murphy USA Inc.?
Both are in the safe zone of the Altman Z-score.
More about Five Below, Inc.
More about Murphy USA Inc.
Sources#
Every figure on this page comes from these, with the date shown next to it.