Insperity, Inc. vs Paychex, Inc.
Market value, revenue, profit, valuation and financial strength side by side, each from the company's own filings or market data, with its date.
In short
- Paychex, Inc. is the larger company by market value: $38.9 B against $1.8 B for Insperity, Inc., 22 times as much (market caps of Oct 30, 2026).
- Insperity, Inc. had more revenue: $6.8 B in the year to December 2025 against $6.5 B for Paychex, Inc. in the year to May 2026.
- Paychex, Inc. made a net profit of $1.8 B, while Insperity, Inc. made a net loss of $7 M.
- Paychex, Inc. keeps more of each dollar of sales: a net margin of 27.0% against -0.1% for Insperity, Inc.
- Paychex, Inc. employs more people: 17,600 against 2,900 at Insperity, Inc. Each employee brings in about $2,348,966 of revenue at Insperity, Inc. and $370,000 at Paychex, Inc.
- On price to earnings, Insperity, Inc. trades at 587.8× and Paychex, Inc. at 21.6×: investors pay more for each dollar of Insperity, Inc.'s profit.
- Paychex, Inc.'s revenue grew faster in its latest fiscal year: +16.9% against +3.5% for Insperity, Inc.
- On the Piotroski F-score, a nine-point test of improving finances, Insperity, Inc. scores 1 and Paychex, Inc. 7. Both are in the safe zone of the Altman Z-score.
- Dividend yield: 5.10% for Insperity, Inc. and 4.08% for Paychex, Inc.
Market value, the same start = 100
From Jan 2020: how each one's value moved, whatever its size.
Revenue by fiscal year
US$ billions, as reported in each year's annual results.
Side by side
| Measure | Insperity, Inc. NSP · #6,857 in the world | Paychex, Inc. PAYX · #664 in the world |
|---|---|---|
| Profile | ||
| Country | 🇺🇸 USA | 🇺🇸 USA |
| Sector | Industrials | Industrials |
| Industry | Staffing and Employment Services | Staffing and Employment Services |
| Founded | 1986 | 1971 |
| Size | ||
| Market cap | $1.8 B | $38.9 B |
| Revenue | $6.8 B | $6.5 B |
| Net income | $-7 M | $1.8 B▲ best |
| Employees | 2,900 | 17,600 |
| Valuation | ||
| P/E ratio | 588× | 21.6× |
| Price to sales | 0.3× | 5.9× |
| Price to book | 38.3× | 10.4× |
| Free cash flow yield | -17.5% | 6.0%▲ best |
| Profitability | ||
| Gross margin | 13.2% | 74.3%▲ best |
| Operating margin | -0.1% | 38.5%▲ best |
| Net margin | -0.1% | 27.0%▲ best |
| Return on equity | -9.8% | 44.8%▲ best |
| Return on invested capital | — | 26.1% |
| Growth | ||
| Revenue growth | 3.5% | 16.9%▲ best |
| Revenue growth, 3 years a year | 4.7% | 9.2%▲ best |
| Earnings per share growth | — | 6.8% |
| Financial strength | ||
| Debt to equity | 8.0× | 1.2×▲ best |
| Net debt to EBITDA | -7.8×▲ best | 1.2× |
| Interest cover | -0.4× | 9.3×▲ best |
| Cash | ||
| Free cash flow margin | -4.5% | 35.6%▲ best |
| Shareholder returns | ||
| Dividend yield | 5.1%▲ best | 4.1% |
| Shareholder yield | 6.2%▲ best | 5.7% |
| Strength scores | ||
| Piotroski F-score | 1 of 9 | 7 of 9▲ best |
| Altman Z-score zone | safe | safe |
| Data as of | Market cap Oct 2026; ratios FY2025 | Market cap Oct 2026; ratios FY2025 |
▲ marks the better of the two where higher or lower is better; size and valuation multiples are marked for neither
Questions and answers#
Which is bigger, Insperity, Inc. or Paychex, Inc.?
Paychex, Inc. is the larger company by market value: $38.9 B against $1.8 B for Insperity, Inc., 22 times as much (market caps of Oct 30, 2026).
Which makes more money, Insperity, Inc. or Paychex, Inc.?
Insperity, Inc. had more revenue: $6.8 B in the year to December 2025 against $6.5 B for Paychex, Inc. in the year to May 2026. Paychex, Inc. made a net profit of $1.8 B, while Insperity, Inc. made a net loss of $7 M.
Which is more profitable, Insperity, Inc. or Paychex, Inc.?
Paychex, Inc. keeps more of each dollar of sales: a net margin of 27.0% against -0.1% for Insperity, Inc.
Which has more employees, Insperity, Inc. or Paychex, Inc.?
Paychex, Inc. employs more people: 17,600 against 2,900 at Insperity, Inc. Each employee brings in about $2,348,966 of revenue at Insperity, Inc. and $370,000 at Paychex, Inc.
Is Insperity, Inc. cheaper than Paychex, Inc.?
On price to earnings, Insperity, Inc. trades at 587.8× and Paychex, Inc. at 21.6×: investors pay more for each dollar of Insperity, Inc.'s profit. A lower multiple is not by itself a better buy: it also reflects expected growth, risk and accounting.
Which is growing faster, Insperity, Inc. or Paychex, Inc.?
Paychex, Inc.'s revenue grew faster in its latest fiscal year: +16.9% against +3.5% for Insperity, Inc.
Which is financially stronger, Insperity, Inc. or Paychex, Inc.?
On the Piotroski F-score, a nine-point test of improving finances, Insperity, Inc. scores 1 and Paychex, Inc. 7. Both are in the safe zone of the Altman Z-score.
More about Insperity, Inc.
More about Paychex, Inc.
Sources#
Every figure on this page comes from these, with the date shown next to it.